Letters and Appeals
22 March 2017
Thank you Mr. President,
This year the Israeli occupation will enter its fiftieth year, and the closure of Gaza will enter its tenth. The pursuant breakdown in human rights and systematic violations of the laws of war in the occupied Palestinian territory continue to be propped up by an Israeli legal system that is geared towards protecting the impunity of its armed forces and political leadership, and by ineffective intervention by the international community to secure justice and legal accountability.
Concerning Operation Protective Edge, Al Mezan and Adalah filed complaints on 28 incidents of suspected serious international humanitarian and human rights law violations to the Israeli authorities, demanding that they open independent criminal investigations and prosecute those responsible. Al Mezan also filed an additional 107 complaints concerning suspected war crimes.
Two and a half years after the bombardment, Israel has not opened a single investigation into any of Al Mezan’s 107 serious criminal complaints, and among Adalah and Al Mezan’s 28 complaints, not a single indictment has been issued. Only incidents of looting by Israeli soldiers and abuse of civilians in military detention were prosecuted, which reflects the Israeli leadership's stated position during the Operation of investigating and prosecuting what qualify as 'common crimes'.[1] The investigations into a few of the serious attacks on UNRWA shelters and civilian targets were closed without further procedures.
Even in the case where the MAG recognized that a missile attack, which killed five members of the Abu Dahrouj family including two children, was carried out directly on a home and did not target any combatant or military objective, no investigation was opened. The MAG stated that “for an unclear reason, likely an unexpected technical malfunction”, the missile hit the home of the family. The case was closed without any action against those involved.
Concerning civil redress, the residents of Gaza continue to face severe barriers in accessing justice in Israel. The overarching challenge remains the mounting legislative restrictions that shield the government from torts liability for its troops’ and commanders’ actions.
The handling of our serious complaints has proven what we have long experienced: Israel is unwilling to conduct genuine, independent investigations into suspected war crimes and does not hold those responsible to account as required by international law.[2] This continues to be the case even after the Israeli military established its Fact-Finding Assessment Mechanism.
We call on the Human Rights Council and members states to:
Thank you.
[1] See " Defense Minister Ya’alon: No Place for Criminal Probe of Gaza War’s Black Friday'", Haaretz, 8 January 2015, available at http://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium-1.636074, last accessed on 29 August 2016.
[2] See Adalah's submission to the UN Commission of Inquiry on the 2014 Gaza Conflict: http://www.adalah.org/en/content/view/8417.
[3] See Resolution of the United Nations Human Rights Council, A/HRC/31/L.38, 22 March 2016.
Face the Public Publications
Israeli Attacks on Palestinians and Properties and Victims of Internal Violence, Monthly Statistical Report
Mezan In Media
Goldstone Report
Press Releases
UN General Assembly Member States Must Stand Against Israel’s Occupation, Apartheid and Genocide
Open Letter to the UN Security Council: Ceasefire Urgently Needed Amid Israel’s Genocidal Massacre in Rafah, Defying ICJ Provisional Measures Orders
Al Mezan Calls on UN Human Rights Chief to Recognize Gaza Genocide and Mobilize International Action at HRC 55
Palestinian Organisations Send Submission to the Special Rapporteur on Extrajudicial, Summary or Arbitrary Executions on Israel’s Continued Oppression of Palestinians Beyond Their Killing
Palestinian Organizations Demand Inquiry Into UN Genocide Prevention Office’s Inexcusable Failure to Address Israel’s Ongoing Genocide in Gaza